How to Pick Which Task to Automate First
Last Tuesday, I spent forty-five minutes copying and pasting information from form submissions into a spreadsheet. Forty-five minutes. I caught myself on the third cup of coffee, hunched over my keyboard, mindlessly clicking between tabs like some kind of data-entry robot. That’s when it hit me — I was doing the machine’s job while the machine sat there waiting to help.
The frustrating part? I’d been meaning to automate this task for months. But every time I sat down to actually do it, I got overwhelmed. There were dozens of repetitive tasks eating up my week. Where was I supposed to start?
The Overwhelm Is Real
Here’s what nobody tells you about automation: the hardest part isn’t learning the tools. It’s deciding what to tackle first. When you realize how much of your work is repetitive, the list gets long fast. Email responses. Data entry. File organization. Social media scheduling. Client follow-ups. Invoice reminders. The list goes on.
I made the classic mistake early on. I tried to automate everything at once. Built a complicated workflow that connected five different platforms, broke it within a week, and gave up for three months. Sound familiar?
The problem wasn’t automation itself. It was my approach. I was trying to run before I could walk.
The Framework That Changed Everything
After that failure, I stumbled across a simple decision-making framework while reading about workflow design. It wasn’t groundbreaking, but it finally gave me clarity. The idea is to evaluate each potential automation task using three criteria: frequency, simplicity, and pain level.
Frequency means how often you do the task. Daily beats weekly. Weekly beats monthly. The more often something happens, the more time you’ll save by automating it.
Simplicity refers to how straightforward the task is. Does it follow the same steps every time? Are there clear rules? Tasks with lots of exceptions and judgment calls are harder to automate well.
Pain level is about how much you dread doing it. Some tasks are quick but soul-crushing. Others take longer but you don’t mind them. The ones that make you groan when they pop up? Those deserve attention.
How I Applied This to My Own Work
I grabbed a notebook and listed every repetitive task I’d done in the past week. Then I rated each one on those three criteria, scoring them from one to five. The results surprised me.
My first instinct had been to automate my email sequences — they felt like the biggest time commitment. But when I scored them, they only happened weekly and required judgment calls about personalization. Not ideal for a first automation.
That form-to-spreadsheet copying? It scored high on all three. I did it daily. It followed identical steps every single time. And I absolutely dreaded it. Perfect starting point.
So I opened up a free automation tool and built my first real workflow. Trigger: new form submission. Action: add row to spreadsheet. That’s it. Took me about twenty minutes to set up, including watching a tutorial video because I’d never configured a trigger node before.
What Actually Changed
The immediate impact was obvious — I stopped doing that forty-five-minute task entirely. But something else happened that I didn’t expect. Building that first simple automation gave me confidence. I understood how triggers worked. I knew how to connect platforms. The second automation took half the time to build.
Within a few weeks, I’d automated five different tasks. None of them were complicated. All of them followed the same pattern: high frequency, simple rules, high annoyance factor. My workflow builder went from intimidating to familiar.
More importantly, I stopped feeling like I was constantly behind. Those small tasks had been creating a steady background hum of stress. Every time I remembered I needed to update that spreadsheet or send that follow-up, it pulled at my attention. Now those things just happen.
Key Takeaways
Start smaller than you think you should. Your first automation should be almost embarrassingly simple. One trigger, one action. Get that working before you build anything complex.
Use the frequency-simplicity-pain framework. Write down your repetitive tasks and actually score them. Your gut might mislead you about what to prioritize.
Don’t automate tasks that require judgment — yet. Save the complicated stuff for when you’ve got some experience. Those workflows are possible, but they’re not beginner-friendly.
Accept that your first attempt might break. Mine did. Build it anyway. You’ll learn faster from a broken workflow than from endless planning.
Track what you’ve automated. I keep a simple list. It’s motivating to see it grow, and it helps you remember what’s running in the background.
Your Turn
Grab that notebook. Spend ten minutes listing every repetitive task you’ve done this week. Score them honestly. Pick the one that scores highest across all three criteria. Then build something simple — one trigger, one action. Don’t overthink it.
The goal isn’t to build the perfect system on day one. It’s to build something that works today and teaches you for tomorrow.
This article is for educational purposes only. Results vary based on individual effort and circumstances.
Want to learn the exact tools and systems I use? Get the free resource guide at snapsidehustles.com